skip to Main Content
Top Non-Dairy Yogurt Recipes Online

Top Non-Dairy Yogurt Recipes Online

Our team gets a lot of questions about how to make non-dairy yogurt. Making soy yogurt is fairly straightforward and similar to making dairy yogurt. But many consumers have written in about making almond and coconut yogurt. We have been testing different recipes for making yogurt with almond and coconut milk and we are in the process of refining our posts on these subjects.

In the meantime, we have found numerous experienced and reputable bloggers who have posted about making almond and coconut milk yogurt at home and we wanted to share a few of our personal faves with everyone.


coconut yogurt


One of the foremost misconceptions out there is that you can make almond milk yogurt with a carton of almond milk that you buy off the shelf or from the refrigerator case at the grocery store. In all of recipes featured below, the bloggers call for making your own almond milk from scratch. Although it may sound difficult, making your own almond milk is actually something even a nut milk neophyte can easily master.

You can soak your almonds overnight and, using a blender, create an almond/water slurry that you can strain using a nut milk bag and a mason jar. In any case, the best practice in making almond milk yogurt at home is to start with fresh, homemade almond milk.


Making coconut milk yogurt is different than making almond milk yogurt because you can start with canned coconut milk. Keep in mind, you cannot make yogurt with coconut water, you have to be using coconut milk (made from the meat of the coconut.) There are many different brands of canned coconut milk available and we are currently testing a variety of brands.


The coconut and almond milk yogurt that is available at the supermarket has many other ingredients added to it to achieve a thick consistency. There are many natural and gluten-free ingredients that you can buy online or at your local health-food store that can help make your coconut milk yogurt thicker. Some of these are: arrowroot powder, agar (aka Agar Agar), tapioca starch, or carageen. Many dairy yogurts use gelatin as an added thickener and there is also a vegetable gum based “vegan gelatin” which is on the market.


And without further ado, the listings. If you come across a blog that you should feel should be included in this post, please email me at cat[at]


Blog: Lexie’s Kitchen
Milk Used: Almond Milk
Article: Almond Milk Yogurt | Dairy Free
Our Take: Wow, we are in awe of Lexie and her comprehensive, easy-to-follow recipes for non-dairy yogurt. She’s also super-responsive and the extensive conversation/comments on this recipe are a testament to her great rapport with her readers.

Blog: FairyTaleComesAlive
Milk Used: Almond Milk
Article: Recipe: Almond Milk Yogurt
Our Take: This is a simple recipe from Krysta, a vegan and young mother of an adorable son who blogs from her home in Greece. She also has a post about making almond milk as well.

Blog: Small Footprint Family
Milk Used: Almond Milk
Article: Homemade Almond Milk Yogurt
Our Take: With step by step directions and tons of helpful tips and tricks, this almond milk yogurt recipe from Small Footprint Family makes yogurt making fun and easy!


Blog: Lexie’s Kitchen
Milk Used: Coconut Milk
Article: Dairy-Free Coconut Milk Yogurt Recipe
Our Take: Once again, Lexie brings home the (veggie) bacon with this all-star recipe for coconut milk yogurt. Alexa Croft, author of Lexie’s Kitchen, tests and re-tests her recipes and gives you a really specific roadmap to achieving successful results.

Blog: Nom Nom Paleo
Milk Used: Coconut Milk
Article: Paleo Plan’s Simple Coconut Milk Yogurt
Our Take:  This is a great fast & easy coconut milk yogurt recipe. A good intro to making coconut milk yogurt with no muss, no fuss.

Blog: Cultures for Health
Milk Used: Coconut Milk
Article: How To Make Coconut Milk Yogurt
Our Take: Cultures for Health is a great source for purchasing starter cultures and they are extremely knowledgeable about yogurt cultures. This is an in-depth, step-by-step guide to making coconut milk yogurt. A must-read for the aspiring coconut yogurt jedi.

Blog: Small Footprint Family
Milk Used: Coconut Milk
Article: Easy Homemade Coconut Milk Yogurt
Our Take: Another great recipe from Small Footprint Family – these guys just get it!